ALA News
Cyber losses and your practice: insurance gaps, breach notice duties and your digital seal

After a cyber incident, the stolen money is often only part of the cost. Your professional liability policy may exclude the loss, state law may require you to notify the people whose information was exposed, and anyone with a copy of your seal file can place it on documents you never reviewed.
Your professional liability policy may exclude it
Professional liability policies are written for design errors. In 2025 an Illinois appellate court held that the cyber events exclusion in an architects and engineers policy meant the carrier had no duty to defend a construction manager against a $673,384 wire fraud claim that ended in a $725,000 consent judgment. The order is nonprecedential and turns on one policy's wording, so treat it as a reason to read your own policy.
Ask your broker these questions and get the answers in writing:
- Does my professional liability policy exclude cyber events or funds transfer losses?
- Do I have a stand-alone cyber policy, or an endorsement that covers social engineering and funds transfer fraud?
- What is the limit for those losses, and is it a sublimit lower than the policy limit?
- Does the coverage apply when my firm is tricked into sending money?
- Does it apply when a client loses money after relying on an email from my account?
Cyber applications ask about multi-factor authentication, backups and other controls. Answer them accurately, and make sure the controls you describe are in place.
A breach can create a notice duty
Firms hold personal information on staff and clients:
- Social Security numbers on payroll and tax forms
- Driver's license numbers
- Bank account details
- User names with passwords
Illinois law (the Personal Information Protection Act) requires a business that holds Illinois residents' personal information to notify them of a breach in the most expedient time possible and without unreasonable delay. The Attorney General must also be notified when more than 500 Illinois residents are affected.
Every state has its own breach notice law, and the law that applies follows where the affected people live. A Chicago firm with a remote employee in Indiana, or a client who lives in Florida, may owe notice under those states' laws too. Check the attorney general's guidance for each state where your employees and clients live.
Protect your digital seal from theft
States accept electronic seals. Wisconsin's rules for architects and engineers, for example, allow public documents completed by digital placement of a seal and an electronic signature with the credential holder's name and date, and say that any other signature standard set by statute governs. The rules do not say how to protect the seal file.
- Keep seal and signature files in one folder that only the licensed professional can open, behind multi-factor authentication.
- Do not email them, and do not leave them in project templates.
- Use a certificate-based digital signature, such as a password-protected digital ID in your PDF software. It records who signed and when and shows if the document changed afterward.
- Check your state board's rules before you change how you seal.
Sources: Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London v. Galey Consulting, 2025 IL App (1st) 241909-U. Illinois Attorney General, Data Breach guidance for businesses (815 ILCS 530). Wisconsin Administrative Code A-E 2.02.
Questions
Which state's breach law applies to our firm?
The law of each state where the affected people live. A firm in Illinois with employees or clients in other states may owe notice under several states' laws.
What should we ask our insurance broker about cyber coverage?
Whether the professional liability policy excludes cyber events, whether you carry coverage for social engineering and funds transfer fraud, and what the limit for those losses is, since many cyber policies set a lower sublimit for them.
Is a pasted image of our seal secure?
No. Anyone with the image file can place it. Keep the file locked down and use a certificate-based digital signature that records who signed and when, after checking your state board's rules.
