Skip to content

The Midwest Architecture Conference is back · August 19, 2027 · NapervilleSee the conference

ALA News

How email wire fraud reaches architecture firms, and the phone rule that prevents it

Illustrative image: an architect on the phone confirming a change to bank details shown in an email.
Illustrative image: an architect on the phone confirming a change to bank details shown in an email.

Business email compromise is the cyber loss small firms report most often. A criminal gets into an email account, reads the billing on a project, then sends new payment instructions that look routine. The defense is a written rule that no payment change is accepted until someone confirms it by phone at a number already on file, and your clients need the same rule for payments they send you.

How it reaches a design or construction firm

Retainers, consultant invoices, pay applications and contractor draws all move by email. The usual sequence:

  1. The attacker steals a password through a fake sign-in link.
  2. Inside the mailbox, they set rules that hide or forward messages so nobody notices.
  3. They wait for an invoice or draw to come due.
  4. They reply in the same thread with new bank details. Some register a look-alike domain one letter off from yours and join the thread from there.

Because the message arrives inside a real conversation, it looks routine.

What it costs

  • Email compromise and fraudulent funds transfers made up 58% of the claims Coalition's policyholders filed in 2025.
  • Coalition's average funds transfer fraud claim was $141,000. Email compromise claims that did not end in a wire averaged $27,000.
  • NetDiligence studied 548 construction claims from 2020 through 2024. The average incident cost about $118,000, with a range from $3,400 to $1.7 million.

Both data sets come from insured firms that are often larger than a typical ALA member firm. Read them as benchmarks, not as an expected loss.

A 2025 Illinois case

In Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London v. Galey Consulting, an Illinois appellate court ruled on insurance coverage for a wire fraud loss on a construction project.

  • Attackers got into the email thread, set a rule that hid the client's messages, and sent false wire instructions.
  • $673,384.18 went to a fraudulent account and was never recovered.
  • The client had written "verify wire info over phone to avoid fraud please." The complaint said the consultant confirmed by email in the compromised thread instead.
  • The underlying claim ended in a $725,000 consent judgment.
  • The court held that the consultant's architects and engineers professional liability policy did not have to defend the claim, because of its cyber events exclusion.

The order is nonprecedential and covers one policy's wording. The insured was a construction manager, and negligence was alleged but never decided by a court.

The phone rule, step by step

Write it on one page and give it to everyone who touches billing. It applies to a one-time consultant the same as a long-time subcontractor.

  1. Any new or changed bank instructions, from anyone, are confirmed by phone before money moves.
  2. Call a number from the signed contract, your accounting records or an earlier invoice. Never use a number from the email asking for the change.
  3. Ask the other party to read back the account details.
  4. Note the date, the person you spoke with and the number you called.
  5. A second person approves the change before the first payment goes out.

Put the rule in your contracts and on every invoice: your firm never changes its payment instructions by email alone, and anyone who receives such a request should call your office at the number in the contract.

Two email settings to turn on

  • Multi-factor authentication on every email account. The federal Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) says to enforce it with technical settings, starting with administrator and remote access accounts.
  • Block automatic forwarding of mail to outside addresses, which attackers use to watch billing threads.

If money has already gone out

  1. Call your bank right away and ask it to recall the wire.
  2. File a complaint at ic3.gov, whatever the amount.
  3. Call your insurer's claims line.

The FBI's Recovery Asset Team worked 3,900 incidents in 2025 involving $1.16 billion in attempted theft and froze $679 million, or 58% of the dollars. Frozen money is not always returned, and the odds drop with every hour.

Sources: FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report. Coalition, 2026 Cyber Claims Report. NetDiligence, Cyber Claims Study 2025. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's London v. Galey Consulting, 2025 IL App (1st) 241909-U. CISA, Cyber Essentials and cisa.gov/small-business.

Questions

Can our client be defrauded through our email?

Yes. If an attacker gets into your mailbox, they can send your client new bank instructions for your fee or a contractor's draw. Tell clients in the contract and on invoices that you never change payment instructions by email alone.

What should a firm do in the first hour after a fraudulent wire?

Call the bank and ask for a wire recall, then file at ic3.gov. The FBI froze 58% of the attempted dollars it worked in 2025, and the odds fall as time passes.

What number should we call to confirm a payment change?

A number from the signed contract, your accounting records or an earlier invoice. Never use a phone number that arrives in the email asking for the change.

← All news and stories